The Traitors US Season 4 Odds and Winner Prediction

Last Updated January 8, 2026 10:19 am PST
Cast members celebrating on the red carpet at an awards event, with “The Traitors Odds and Winner Prediction” text overlay and GamblingSites.com branding.

The Traitors season 4 premiere has fans of the popular reality TV show flocking to sportsbooks to wager on their winner prediction. With 23 cast members, there are plenty of familiar faces that fans of reality TV will recognize. 

Betting odds for The Traitors season 4 will be available throughout the season, but placing your wagers early is the best way to lock in high-paying odds. Keep reading to see the latest betting lines for The Traitors‘ winner this season and a closer look at the top contenders. 

The Traitors Season 4 Winner Odds

BetOnline supplied the following opening odds for The Traitors season 4 winner. 

ContestantOdds to Win Traitors US Season 4
Tiffany Mitchell+200
Rob Cesternino+250
Kristen Kish+800
Mark Ballas+800
Maura Higgins+1000
Rob Rausch+1000
Yam Yam+1200
Eric Nam+1200
Lisa Rinna+1200
Natalie Anderson+1200
Porsha Williams+1200
Stephen Colletti+1200
Tara Lipinski+1200

The rest of The Traitors season 4 cast have the following odds:

Icon of entertainment
  • Colton Underwood (+1400)
  • Candice Dillard Bassett (+1400)
  • Ron Funches (+1600)
  • Johnny Weir (+2000)
  • Monet X Change (+2000)
  • Caroline Stanbury (+2000)
  • Donna Kelce (+2000)
  • Dorinda Medley (+2000)
  • Ian Terry (+2000)
  • Michael Rapaport (+2000)

Big Brother alum Tiffany Mitchell is the +200 favorite to win The Traitors this season. Although she did not win her season. Mitchell was a fan favorite before being evicted from the Big Brother house on day 71. 

Two-time Survivor castaway and host of Rob Has a Podcast, Rob Cesternino, has the second-best odds to win Traitors this season at +250. Cesternino never won Survivor, but he has the best odds of any of the three former castaways playing this season. 

After the top two, the odds to win Traitors season 4 fade quickly. Kristen Kish and Mark Ballas are tied for the third-best odds at +800, while Maura Higgins and Rob Rausch have the next-best odds at 10-1 each. 

View the latest odds of The Traitors and other popular reality TV shows at BetOnline. Or check out our free and honest BetOnline review to learn more about this top-notch entertainment betting site. 

Why Is Tiffany Mitchell Favored to Win?

Tiffany Mitchell fell short in her attempt to win Big Brother 23, but she was voted as America’s Favorite HouseGuest that season. Her popularity led to her returning as a guest host in season 24 and Big Brother: Reindeer Games. She later competed on two seasons of The Challenge: USA

Mitchell’s experience in reality TV competitions is not the only reason she is the +200 odds favorite to win The Traitors season 4. She is a great social player and used her skills to build and control alliances that helped her advance deeper into her season of Big Brother

If Mitchell can use her social skills to control this season, she will be a real threat to win. However, her previous experience in recent reality TV competitions could also put a major target on her back early on. 

Can Rob Cesternino Win Traitors Season 4?

Like Mitchell, Rob Cesternino fell short in his reality TV debut. Cesternino finished third in Survivor: The Amazon, the sixth season of the hit show. He later returned for season 8, Survivor: All-Stars, but was the fourth castaway eliminated from the game. 

Despite not winning, Cesternino has remained relevant in the reality TV world thanks to his popular podcast, Rob Has a Podcast. He makes his living discussing and breaking down popular reality TV competitions, including Survivor, The Amazing Race, and Big Brother

It has been a long time since Cesternino competed, but his work covering these types of shows has kept him up to date with the latest players and strategies. That knowledge should serve him well as he returns to reality TV for the first time in over two decades. 

Is Kristen Kish the Best Traitors Winner Sleeper Pick?

Kristen Kish is tied for the third-best odds to win The Traitors at +800, according to top entertainment betting sites. Kish made her name in reality cooking shows, including appearing on and winning season 10 of Top Chef

In the decade and a half since, Kish has continued to appear on reality TV, but mainly as a host. Her only appearance as a contestant was on Top Chef Duels in 2014, where she lost her duel to Top Chef: Chicago winner Stephanie Izard.

Kish has appeared as a host or judge on multiple cooking shows over the years, including, among others:

Icon of entertainment
  • Chopped
  • Chopped Junior
  • Top Chef: Portland
  • Guy’s Grocery Games
  • Fast Foodies

There is no denying her skills as a chef, but Kish will need more than just tasty dishes to win The Traitors. If she is as good at strategizing and deceiving as she is in the kitchen, though, Kish could be a serious player this season. 

More Sleepers to Watch this Season

Icon of entertainment
  • Mark Ballas (+800)
  • Natalie Anderson (+1200)
  • Ron Funches (+1600)

Mark Ballas is tied with Kish at 8-1 odds to win the Traitors season 4. Ballas has competed as a pro on Dancing With the Stars for nearly 20 years, winning three seasons and placing in the top three a total of 10 times. Winning The Traitors will require more than fancy dance moves, though. 

Natalie Anderson is no stranger to reality competitions, either, finishing fourth on The Amazing Race season 21 before winning Survivor: San Juan del Sur in 2014. Nat returned for Survivor: Winners at War, finishing in second place, and later appeared on season 36 of The Challenge. If her skills from Survivor, The Amazing Race, and The Challenge translate, she could be a steal at 12-1 odds. 

Comedian and actor Ron Funches is another intriguing sleeper pick at +1600 odds. He lacks the reality competition experience of other contenders, but Funches’s social skills could give him a major edge. His lack of experience could also allow Funches to fly under the radar as well-known competitors pick each other off. 

Bet
Mark Ballas
(+800)

Traitors Season 4 Winner Prediction

With a cast of nearly two dozen contestants, it is challenging to narrow down the field to just one winner. Of the current players, I think Natalie Anderson (+1200) has the best odds to win the Traitors season 4.

The first season of The Traitors US was one by fellow Survivor alum Cirie Fields. Like Fields, Anderson has proven her skills as a social player. Anderson also has experience on The Challenge, as did season 2 winners CT Tamburello and Trishelle Cannatella. 

Her social skills and ability to adapt to new situations on the fly will allow Anderson to succeed as a Traitor or a Faithful. Her experience sniffing out liars and, at times, lying herself on Survivor should also help Anderson go far in the game. 

Where to Bet on Traitors US Season 4

BetOnline has odds on many popular reality TV competitions, including The Traitors season 4. You can bet on updated odds for every contestant each week, including my season 4 winner pick: Natalie Anderson (+1200). 

Creating a BetOnline account is quick and easy. New members can also get help funding their account by using the code FREE250 to gain up to $250 in free bet funds. 

Photo of Zachary Wolf
Zachary
Wolf
Content Editor
Articles
169
Zachary Wolf is a Content Editor specializing in online gambling content. His writing credits include state-specific U.S. gambling laws, casino reviews, and various sports betting guides — most notably WWE betting guides. He enjoys playing slots, poker, and blackjack, among other games.
Leave Your Comment