On This Page

2021 Rankings of New York Sports Betting Sites

Our compilation of the best New York sports betting sites will provide you with the guidance you need to safely bet online for real money.

We take our recommendations very seriously, so you can rest assured that you will have a positive experience at any of the online sportsbooks that we recommend on this page.

Rank VA Betting Site Exclusive Bonus Get Started
#2 50% Up To $1,000 Visit Site Visit Site
#3 100% Up To $1,000 Visit Site Visit Site
#4 50% Up To $250 Visit Site Visit Site
#5 50% Up To $1,000 Visit Site Visit Site

GamblingSites.com has been providing reading with in-depth information about the best places to bet online for many years. Our team is made up of highly-experienced, passionate professionals with expertise in many aspects of online gambling and sports betting.

Our guide to the best NY sports betting sites can be trusted, just like the online bookmakers and sportsbooks we recommend.

Best New York Sports Betting Sites

New York Sports Betting Sites

Finding the best places to bet online is rarely easy. This is especially true in New York and other American states, as there are complex laws surrounding online betting and gambling that few people truly understand.

This means many of the leading betting sites choose not to accept US customers. It also means there are plenty of shady operations out there, ready and waiting to rip off unsuspecting customers.

You don’t need to worry about any of that. We’ve picked the best New York sports betting sites for you. Our rankings are carefully compiled based on a range of factors, and you can rest assured that they are all safe and reputable sportsbook that provide an excellent online betting experience.

Ranking the Top NY Betting Sites

We evaluate sports betting sites based on a highly refined system we’ve developed and improved over the years. It leaves nothing to chance, as we thoroughly investigate all aspects of every real money gambling site that we might possibly recommend.

When an online sportsbook can get high marks across the board, we’re willing to give them a thumbs up. Here are just a few details on some of the things we look at when ranking the best New York sports betting sites.

Legitimacy Litmus Test

Before we get into an evaluation of features and other details, there’s one starting point that sits above everything else. If a sports betting site can’t be completely trusted to record your bets accurately and safeguard your deposits appropriately, there’s no reason to look deeper.

There are a couple of different points that are assessed when we are determining legitimacy or lack thereof. One of them is the license that is held by a given site, and some entities that issue permits are much more discerning than others.

The top licensing bodies do not issue licenses to unqualified and potentially unscrupulous applicants that are willing to pay the fee.

In many cases, these are countries and territorial jurisdictions that deeply rely on the revenue they receive through their relationships with the online gambling industry. In a real sense, their licenses are among their most valuable commodities, so absolute legitimacy is of crucial importance.

The quality of the license that a site is operating under is key, along with the reputation that has been established. We sometimes hear insider information from other people that we know within the industry, and this gives us an advantage.

There are a number of online sportsbook forums that are frequented by big-time players. Our staff members visit these forums on an ongoing basis to garner insight that can be invaluable during the rating process, in addition to our own impressions.

People that have had these direct experiences take the time to share their impressions in an effort to help other players make good decisions. We don’t make any snap judgments, but when we see supporting evidence, the implications are factored in one way or another.

Account Funding Options

The best sports betting sites in NY offer a wide range of account funding options that are intended to make it easy for people in the United States to make deposits.

Each site has slightly different policies as you might imagine, but they typically take Visa and Mastercard. This would include credit cards along with debit cards, and they accept gift cards, too. The latter option is great for players who don’t have their own permanent cards.

Deposits can be made via wire or ACH transfers. If you’re not familiar with this acronym, it stands for “Automated Clearing House,” a service that facilitates transfers between banks.

One option that you may want to consider, even if you have not embraced the cryptocurrency phenomenon before, is Bitcoin. This enables rapid transfers between you and the online betting site and there’s no middleman. It’s simply a direct virtual currency exchange between two willing parties.

Collecting Your Winnings

Obviously, you have to put out some money to make wagers, but the transactions you really want to make are withdrawals.

Some of the deposit methods can be used in the reverse manner to extract funds. Paper check payments by mail are offered at some internet-based sportsbooks, along with eChecks.

Once again, Bitcoin is the way to go if you want to get paid as quickly as possible. Since there’s no excessive processing involved, you receive your withdrawals almost immediately.

You’ll definitely be able to find a withdrawal method to your liking at our preferred NY betting sites, and with all methods, they transfer funds as soon as they possibly can.

Ease of Navigation, Site Stability, and Mobile Adaptability

All websites exist for a reason, so they don’t want to experience downtime. Consistent reliability is especially important for an online betting website that’s in control of player funds.

They should maintain the level of trust by staying up and running to maximize profitability. The online books that we would consider to be among the best New York sports betting sites have especially strong infrastructures that are capable of handling the data demands.

When you start to use an online sportsbook, you should be able to understand how to use the betting interfaces intuitively. You’re likely to get the hang of it quickly at most well-designed websites.

If a site has made it onto our list of recommended sports betting sites for NY, you’ll be able to find your way around with ease, and they’ll adapt seamlessly to all mobile devices.

Availability of Customer Service

Unfortunately, many internet-based businesses are sorely lacking when it comes to customer service, even some huge companies. Sometimes, they don’t have the resources, and in other instances, they intentionally hide from customers to make contact more difficult.

The online sportsbooks that we rate highly provide fast, efficient, and effective customer support.

The top online betting sites for New York have phone agents that can help you out, and some of their call centers are open 24/7. Email contact is also a readily available method, and there are sites that offer live chat during certain hours.

The Legalization of Sports Betting in New York

A federal law was passed back in 1992 that prohibited sports gambling in every state except Nevada. The Silver State was grandfathered in because it’s built around the gaming industry, but there were no other exceptions to the ban on full-scale sports wagering.

Though they insisted on a pass for their state, Nevada lawmakers were more than glad to help the measure make it through Congress, because such a statute would allow Nevada to continue to hold a monopoly on legal sports gambling in the United States.

This law remained unchallenged until the state of New Jersey placed the issue on the ballot in November of 2011.

A constitutional amendment that would legalize sports gaming in the Garden State was passed by an overwhelming margin of 2 to 1, but there was an immediate roadblock put into place.

The major professional sports leagues in the United States and the NCAA have always contended that legal gambling would make the outcome of the contests questionable. They were concerned about fixed games, so they filed a lawsuit to stop New Jersey from opening state-sanctioned sportsbooks.

Initially, they succeeded, but Chris Christie, the governor at the time, was very adamant about legal sports gaming. He felt as though it could revive the sports gambling industry in his state. Atlantic City casinos had been steadily declining in popularity, and this was part of the motivation.

Christie had a background as a respected federal prosecutor, so he knew the law very well. He believed that the courts would eventually find that the law, which was called the Professional and Amateur Sports Protection Act (PASPA), was unconstitutional.

During the initial phases of litigation, lower courts upheld the constitutionality of the law. State attorneys immediately filed appeals when these negative opinions were handed down. Ultimately, in 2017, the Supreme Court of the United States agreed to hear the case and issue the final say.

They got to the case the following year and, in 2018, a decision was rendered. The majority of the justices agreed that the law was in fact in violation of the Constitution, citing 10th Amendment protection. Since then, individual states have had the right to legalize sports gambling.

Lawmakers in the state of New York apparently anticipated this ruling several years in advance. In 2013, they passed legislation that would allow sportsbooks at commercial casinos along with existing tribal gaming halls.

These land-based sportsbooks are now up and running. Thus far, the state’s sports wagering revenue has been in the millions. It’s quite likely that New York gambling laws will change again in the future, possibly to allow legal and regulated online betting in NY.

Benefits of Betting Online in NY

It’s great that sports betting is legal in New York. The only problem is that these locations aren’t easily accessible to those who reside in other parts of the Empire state.

Betting online at one of the best New York sports betting sites is the ideal solution. Even if there were brick and mortar sportsbooks in other parts of the state, there would still be some compelling reasons to continue to bet on sports online. Here’s a few of them.

Continuous, Immediate Betting Action

Let’s say that they were to expand the sportsbook locations, and there was one about 10 miles from your house (a scenario that is exceedingly unlikely). If you’re an NFL football fan, it wouldn’t be too inconvenient to drive over to the book once a week to make your football bets for Sunday and Monday.

This is great, but on the other hand, do you really want to drive that 10 miles if you don’t have to? Plus, under those circumstances, you would never be able to make a spur-of-the-moment bet.

And when you work and have other responsibilities, you’re not going to run over to the sportsbook every day to bet on daily sports like basketball and baseball.

These limitations simply do not exist when you open an account at a reliable internet betting site. You can pull out your smartphone and have your action in place in a couple of minutes.

Whenever you decide you’re going to sit back and watch a game with some action on it, even if you make a decision 10 minutes before the first pitch, there’s nothing stopping you.

Sign-Up Bonuses, Promotions

At a traditional physical betting location, you might get a complimentary t-shirt if you spend a hundred dollars or more betting on the Super Bowl, but that’s about it when it comes to freebies. Things are entirely different at the best NY betting sites.

They’re all competing for your business, so they want to attract your attention with cash if you pay them a visit. New players receive hefty sign-up bonuses, so you’re immediately eligible for the reward after you make your first deposit.

Depending on the extent of your deposit, we’re talking about bonuses that can reach $1000, so this is a significant perk that will have a tangible impact.

To maximize your rewards as a new player, you can actually deposit funds at multiple different sports gambling websites.

After you receive your sign-up bonus at one New York betting site, you can go ahead and start another account at a different site that offers a juicy bonus, so you can keep racking up the cash.

Shopping for Odds

There is another good reason why it’s wise to open multiple accounts. When you’re stuck with nothing but brick and mortar options, you’re not going to drive from place to place to see if there are any differences in the odds.

This is especially true in a state with with sportsbooks that are at least a couple of hours from the five boroughs.

Any experienced sports gambler knows that an extra point or two, or even a half-point, can make all the difference, and moneylines can vary to some extent.

When you bet at the best New York sports betting sites that we listed, you’re not stuck with a single set of numbers.

As a person with multiple accounts, you can check out the lines on all of the sites and pick and choose the best numbers that are being offered on the teams you like.

You Choose the Environment

If you have to travel to a physical sportsbook to make a bet, you’re stuck with the environment whether you like it or not. You can’t wave a magic wand to change the venue to match your desired surroundings.

On the other hand, when you embrace online sports gambling, you call the shots. You can make your bets on your phone, head over to your favorite sports bar, and hang out with your friends while you watch your action in total comfort.

Another benefit is the simple fact that you don’t have to deal with any rude customers or surly sportsbook writers.

Wager online at the best sites for betting in NY, and your sports betting interactions are completely chill and hassle-free.

Sports Betting Options at Online Sportsbooks

There are no limitations at the best New York sports betting sites. In fact, you can make bets that are often unavailable at some of the land-based books.

Here are some of the most popular betting markets at our recommended online sportsbooks for NY.

NFL and College Football

The most popular sport for betting in the United States is NFL football, and college football is another huge revenue center for the industry. This is a sport that lends itself well to betting, because you have a full week to make your decisions. There’s intense focus because there are a limited number of games.

When you place a bet on an NFL matchup or NCAA football contest, when you watch the game, you are fully invested in every play. Saturdays and Sundays are full of nail-biting excitement from the early afternoon onward, and you can risk as much or as little as you want to make the games interesting.

At most online betting sites There are a number of different types of bets available on the NFL other than point spread, moneyline wagers, and totals bets.

College and Pro Basketball

The best New York sports betting sites provide a great experience for college and pro basketball wagering enthusiasts. On the NCAA side, “March Madness” is one of the most highly-anticipated events of the year, and the NBA postseason is a big draw as well.

Straight bets on sides and totals along with parlays are available on all sports.

In-game wagering is in the mix, along with futures betting, and there can be proposition bets offered on big contests.

Major League Baseball

If you want to bet on the Mets or the Yankees, you’re in business at NY sports gambling websites. Everything is the same as the other sports with regard to the most basic types of wagers, including futures and limited propositions.

Baseball betting is typically done on the moneyline without point spreads, but there’s another option that’s kind of a hybrid between the two.

There is a run line that is always consistent at 1 ½ runs. So, if you bet the favorite at -1 ½, you have to win by at least two runs to collect. The underdog bettor will already be ahead by a run and a half when the game starts.

NHL Wagering

Hockey betting is pretty much identical to baseball. Standard straight bets are on the moneyline, and there’s a 1 ½ goal puck line.

There’s some interest in betting on regular season games, and this is magnified during the NHL playoffs.

Other Sports

In addition to the big four of foundational American sports, the books cater to golf enthusiasts with odds on participants to win big tournaments. The same thing is true for the Grand Slam of tennis.

There are plenty of very passionate NASCAR fans in the United States, especially in certain parts of the country. You will definitely see odds on NASCAR races at internet-based sportsbooks.

Mixed martial arts and boxing are on the menu, and those that have an interest can bet on European soccer and other sports that are played across the pond.

Final Thoughts

The best New York sports betting sites are stable from a technological standpoint, and they’re regulated in reputable jurisdictions. They place an emphasis on the total customer experience, and they sweeten the pot with bonuses and promotions.

You can wager on all major sports, and you can choose from a slate of the standard sports betting options you would see at a Las Vegas book. As long as you stick to the sites that we recommend, you will have a reliable, trustworthy online sportsbook in your pocket at all times.